Butt Plugs

A butt plug is the foundation of anal play — it trains the muscles, builds anticipation and can stay in through other scenes. This collection covers jeweled metal plugs and playful animal-tail plugs, all body-safe and sized for gradual progression.

Choose your shape

A jeweled plug is smooth and wearable: the jeweled metal plug is metal with a gem base in several colours and sizes. Tail plugs add a playful finish — the faux-fur tail plug is a faux-fur animal tail, and the red devil-tail plug is a red silicone devil tail for pet play.

Fit and safety

Start small with plenty of water-based lube, relax, and let the body draw the plug in rather than pushing. The flared base is non-negotiable; never use a toy without one. Go slow, stop on any sharp pain, and clean thoroughly between uses.

Materials

Metal holds temperature (warm or cool for sensation) and is easy to sanitise; silicone is lighter and softer. Both should be body-safe and seamless.

Care

Wash with mild soap and warm water, sanitise silicone or metal as rated, and store in a clean pouch. Inspect for tears before each use.

Related: dildos · fetish wear · collars & leashes
Skip to results list
3 items

Filter

  • Dominitoy Dominitoy Devil Tail Plug – Red Silicone Anal Plug with Black Faux Leather Tail, Kinky Toy

    Dominitoy Devil Tail Plug – Red Silicone with Black Faux Leather Tail

    Dominitoy Devil Tail Plug – Red Silicone with Black Faux Leather Tail
    $19.90
  • Domini Toy Black Fluffy Faux Fur Animal Anal Tail Plug

    Faux Fur Animal Tail Plug – Pet Play BDSM Tail Butt Plug

    Faux Fur Animal Tail Plug – Pet Play BDSM Tail Butt Plug
    $12.00
  • Domini Toy Metal Jeweled Butt Plug, 3 Sizes, Non-Porous, Multi-Color Gems

    Metal Jeweled Butt Plug – Body-Safe, 3 Sizes, 6 Gem Colors

    Metal Jeweled Butt Plug – Body-Safe, 3 Sizes, 6 Gem Colors
    $4.90

Butt PlugsButt Plugs | Silicone & Metal Anal Toys | DominitoyShop body-safe butt plugs at Dominitoy. Silicone tail plugs, jeweled metal plugs & pet play tail plugs. Beginner-friendly.Comfortable exploration starts with the right fit.

What Are Butt Plugs?

A butt plug is a specially designed anal toy with a tapered tip and flared base.

Our Butt Plug Collection

Silicone Tail Plugs for Pet Play

Our Devil Tail Plug features a red silicone plug with a black faux leather tail — perfect for pet play and roleplay scenarios. The Faux Fur Animal Tail Plug offers a softer, more playful option with faux fur tail in various colors.

Metal Jeweled Butt Plugs

The Metal Jeweled Butt Plug combines a polished, weighty feel with a decorative gem base. Available in 3 sizes and 6 gem colors, these plugs are easy to clean, temperature-play friendly, and popular for both beginners and experienced users.

How to Choose Your First Butt Plug

  • Start with silicone — body-safe, flexible, and easier to insert
  • Choose the right size — our metal plugs come in 3 sizes for gradual exploration
  • Consider tail plugs for pet play — adds a visual and psychological dimension
  • Always use water-based lubricant — silicone toys require water-based lube

Butt Plug Safety Tips

Always use lubricant: The anus does not self-lubricate. Use plenty of water-based lube.
Go slow: Insert gently, never force it.
Flared base is mandatory: Never use a toy without a flared base anally.
Clean thoroughly: Wash with warm water and mild soap before and after each use.

Explore our full range of butt plugs, anal toys, and pet play accessories at Dominitoy. Whether you are shopping for a silicone tail plug, a jeweled metal butt plug, or your first beginner-friendly anal toy, you will find body-safe materials, discreet shipping, and pieces designed for comfortable exploration.